It's a 'scandalous waste of money' that Finchley hospital remains half empty

By Dave Speck in Local People

A STATE-OF-THE-ART hospital is half-empty more than four years after being built due to a disagreement over rent and running costs.

In a situation described as “scandalous,” Finchley Memorial Hospital, in Granville Road, is half-empty because different parts of the NHS cannot agree over terms and conditions for renting it out to GP surgeries and other healthcare providers.

Health spokesman for Barnet Council’s Labour group Phil Cohen said that a chance was being missed to ease some of the “major unsustainable pressure” on the NHS and called on the Barnet CCG, the NHS body which commissions the borough’s health services, to solve the problem quickly.

Mr Cohen said that the hospital could help ease the beds shortage at the Barnet and Royal Free hospitals and that there was scope to accommodate community health facilities such as a minor injuries unit or physiotherapy unit.

He said: “It doesn’t make any sense to be commissioning services for half the hospital while leaving the other half-empty.

"It’s poor economics and a very poor use of taxpayers’ money.

“One of the problems is that it’s been incredibly difficult to find out who is responsible for setting the rent and paying the money.”

The hospital currently houses a walk-in centre and a falls clinic as well as children’s orthopaedics and language therapy services, among other services, but rooms on upper floors are said to be empty.

Richard Cornelius, leader of the Barnet Council, agreed with Mr Cohen at last week’s full council meeting that the situation was “a scandal” and called for “flexibility in terms and conditions, so the hospital can be filled”.

Mr Cornelius said: “It remains under-occupied because of rules set by the NHS property company about facilities management costs and rent levels, which make it unattractive for GPs and other NHS providers to rent the site.”

When contacted by The Press, a spokesman for Barnet CCG said it was “working closely” with other bodies within the NHS and “making

significant progress” towards securing a range of new services at the hospital.

He said a programme to provide new services called Reimagining Finchley Memorial would be launched later this year. “We are taking a pioneering approach with GPs across Barnet to base a primary care hub at the site, alongside diagnostic, community health and care and well-being services,”added the spokesman.

“We will also work closely with the local community to explore what additional services could be provided from Finchley and we have already engaged the voluntary sector.”

Add Comment
Add Comment


Comments are not moderated

Richard Healy (CEO - Barnet Community Transport) · 127 days ago · Report

Barnet Community Transport (BCT) welcomes any initiative that helps to ease pressure on NHS facilities in Barnet. We already provide transport for patients referred to the Older Persons Assessment Unit at Chase Farm Hospital. This assists the reduction in numbers, of that age group, attending A&E at Barnet General Hospital. BCT vehicles visited FMH only last week for a day out for members of the Dementia Club UK. As an independent local charity, BCT resources are available to help support existing and new service provision at the Hospital to increase usage amongst those who are elderly, frail, or have mobility difficulties and would otherwise be restricted in accessing NHS facilities. We await developments with interest as we share the eagerness of the cross party support expressed in this article, and are ready to help tackle the many challenges in getting this excellent resource and space, that lies within FMH, up to full utilisation as soon as possible.

Add Your Comment

You don't need an account to leave a comment

By posting your comment you agree to our T & C